manifests are accessing root level templates

That was added in Pull 31 which there has been some debate about anyway. That bit probably wants backing out.

https://github.com/CiscoSystems/grizzly-manifests/pull/31

Adding Daneyon, Michael, and Ian for input based on their comments in the review.

Also, @bodepd, can you elaborate on the "specific issues" you're seeing?

in my case, it's just a pain to have to copy this extra template around. I saw backwards compatibility issues between 2.7 and 3.2 (I have to set templatedir in 3.2 explicitly). Research showed that this practice is no longer recommended by PuppetLabs which means that we should not be doing it (b/c it may not be supported, or may lead to unexpected behavior). It would be really easy to not do it and replace the template call with a string.

I think core.pp, cobbler_node.pp and any templates required by either
should be in a separate module, not in manifests.

I would prefer the only thing in manifests to be site.pp.

 - Michael

On 6/06/13 3:10 AM, "Dan Bode" <email address hidden> wrote:

>in my case, it's just a pain to have to copy this extra template around.
>I saw backwards compatibility issues between 2.7 and 3.2 (I have to set
>templatedir in 3.2 explicitly). Research showed that this practice is no
>longer recommended by PuppetLabs which means that we should not be doing
>it (b/c it may not be supported, or may lead to unexpected behavior). It
>would be really easy to not do it and replace the template call with a
>string.
>
>--
>You received this bug notification because you are subscribed to the bug
>report.
>https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1187583
>
>Title:
> manifests are accessing root level templates
>
>Status in Openstack @ Cisco:
> New
>Status in Cisco Openstack grizzly series:
> Confirmed
>
>Bug description:
> Currently, the cobbler-node.pp file is accessing a root level
> template:
>
> $interfaces_file=regsubst(template("interfaces.erb"), '$',
> "\\n\\", "G")
>
> This is problematic for several reasons, it requires that an extra
> templates directory be managed, and it is no longer recommended:
>
> http://docs.puppetlabs.com/guides/templating.html
>
> I am seeing specific issues
>
> it looks like this is the only place where this template is used, this
> line should be replaces with a static string.
>
>To manage notifications about this bug go to:
>https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-cisco/+bug/1187583/+subscriptions

I agree that as much logic as possible should be represented as classes in modules.