Comment 233 for bug 11334

Revision history for this message
pyrates (pyrates18) wrote :

I've been watching the comments carefully over the past few days and we seem to be falling into the same traps previous comments already have mentioned but we can't do:

1. It's already spec'd out on a per application basis on how to properly implement it on linux.
-this spec has been around for years and we only have a few applications that follow it
-the reason why most linux developers don't follow it is because they don't like it
-when they develop versions of their software on windows or mac os x, they don't need to jump through these extra hoops to get it working with the clipboard
-so because they don't have to do it in windows and mac os x, they feel they shouldn't have to on linux either
-remember developers are inherently lazy and anything that makes it easier to work with your platform, they will use
-this implementation makes it harder to work with linux and they clearly don't like the spec
2. We got a clipboard manager already, just install that
-this is a bandaid solution
-only works with text
-not installed by default
-there must be one developed for each DE and its the equivalent of reinventing the wheel over and over which seems to occur in open source quite often I notice
3. Implement and fix it on Xorg itself
-this is the right solution as it's where the clipboard exists
-won't need multiple versions for each DE out there as each DE would immediately get it
-needs to be spec'd out as it's only an idea right now
-reasons why old school linux developers won't implement it and a new generation of linux developers will have to work on it:
http://elliotth.blogspot.com/2008/08/desktop-linux-suckage-clipboard.html