[acx111] default firmware not working for acx d-link dwl-g650+

Bug #60905 reported by David Planella
2
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
linux-source-2.6.17 (Ubuntu)
Invalid
Undecided
Unassigned

Bug Description

This bug is simply https://launchpad.net/distros/ubuntu/+source/linux-source-2.6.15/+bug/30766 appearing again in linux-source-2.6.17.

Quoting http://acx100.sourceforge.net/wiki/Firmware:

<quote>
For ACX111 there are only 2 really supported firmwares, and people have had best results with the first one:

acx111 firmware 1.2.1.34 mirror
acx111 firmware 1.2.0.30 mirror
</quote>

However, after testing the knot3 cd on my laptop and noticing that wifi wasn't working, I saw that again the 2.3.1.31 firmware is loaded per default. And as stated before, the 0.3.2.1 acx driver shipped by ubuntu does *not* work with the 2.3.1.31 firmware.

The output of 'dmesg | grep acx' states it:

[17179711.988000] acx: firmware 'Rev 2.3.1.31' does not work well with this driver
[17179711.988000] acx: form factor 0x01 ((mini-)PCI / CardBus), radio type 0x16 (Radia), EEPROM version 0x05, uploaded firmware 'Rev 2.3.1.31' (0x03010101)
[17179711.988000] acx v0.3.21: net device wlan0, driver compiled against wireless extensions 20 and Linux 2.6.17-7-generic

So the default firmware for the acx111 driver should be firmware 1.2.1.34 instead of 2.3.1.31

Could anyone please confirm?

Revision history for this message
David Planella (dpm) wrote :

Marked as a duplicate

Changed in linux-source-2.6.17:
status: Unconfirmed → Rejected
Revision history for this message
sunwave (gerald-eggenberger) wrote :

I'm Testing an ACX111 based Zyxel G-360 on Kubuntu Edgy:

As you can see at the following output, i've tryed a lot of firmware to get working with edgy. But with no success.

root@edgy:/lib/firmware/2.6.17-10-386/acx# dmesg | grep acx
[17179590.464000] acx: Loaded combined PCI/USB driver, firmware_ver=1.2.1.34
[17179590.464000] acx: compiled to use 32bit I/O access. I/O timing issues might occur, such as non-working firmware upload. Report them
[17179590.468000] usbcore: registered new driver acx_usb
[17179975.528000] usbcore: deregistering driver acx_usb
[17179981.456000] acx: Loaded combined PCI/USB driver, firmware_ver=1.2.1.30
[17179981.456000] acx: compiled to use 32bit I/O access. I/O timing issues might occur, such as non-working firmware upload. Report them
[17179981.456000] usbcore: registered new driver acx_usb
[17179998.796000] usbcore: deregistering driver acx_usb
[17180089.672000] acx: Loaded combined PCI/USB driver, firmware_ver=1.9.8.b
[17180089.672000] acx: compiled to use 32bit I/O access. I/O timing issues might occur, such as non-working firmware upload. Report them
[17180089.672000] usbcore: registered new driver acx_usb
[17180362.592000] usbcore: deregistering driver acx_usb
[17180366.960000] acx: Loaded combined PCI/USB driver, firmware_ver=2.3.1.31
[17180366.960000] acx: compiled to use 32bit I/O access. I/O timing issues might occur, such as non-working firmware upload. Report them
[17180366.960000] usbcore: registered new driver acx_usb
[17180496.256000] usbcore: deregistering driver acx_usb
[17180500.568000] acx: Loaded combined PCI/USB driver, firmware_ver=1.0.9
[17180500.568000] acx: compiled to use 32bit I/O access. I/O timing issues might occur, such as non-working firmware upload. Report them
[17180500.568000] usbcore: registered new driver acx_usb

As described in the following wiki, it should work in edgy.
http://acx100.sourceforge.net/wiki/Distribution_list/Ubuntu

I would try to follow the build instructions...

Revision history for this message
David Planella (dpm) wrote :

> As described in the following wiki, it should work in edgy.

Note that the wiki says "it seems to work", not that "it should". I happen to be the one who wrote that, and chose the wording with caution, since that statement is based on own experience (I own an acx11-based DWL-G650+) and on posts from the ubuntu forums.

This bug is about the incorrect firmware being loaded at startup.

Your problem is that your wifi card (or the driver) is not functioning properly I would rather post a separate bug for that, specifying *exactly* what is not working.

A quick search on the forums seems to hint that such a card should be working with the acx driver (http://www.ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=278692&highlight=Zyxel+G-360), but have you checked that such card is supported by the driver?

Revision history for this message
sunwave (gerald-eggenberger) wrote : AW: [Bug 60905] Re: [acx111] default firmware not working for acx d-linkdwl-g650+

Hi

Thanks for answering so far... I've read a lot of threads and it seems to
me, that none of them got a working solution for a zyxel G-360 on edgy eft
using kernel 2.6.17-10.

To figure this out, I've created a thread
http://www.ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=313453

In Edgy Eft there are several Firmwareversions included. I've tested them
all with adding "options acx firmware_ ver=1.2. 1.34" in

/etc/modprobe.d/options

I also tried to compile my own driver for edgy as described in
http://acx100.sourceforge.net/wiki/ACX

but without Luck.

I also tried to use ndiswrapper with the same bad result.

Dmesg ¦ grep acx

Give me all the time a timing error as a matter of wrong firmware.

The last thing I try to figure out is IRQ-Problems. I've read in a thread,
that someone had such a problem.

If I am sure that I've tried all I could, I'll open a bug-report with
all my informations.

If you also have any ideas/hints to test, please send them to me.

Thanks in advance.

Best regards.
Gérald Eggenberger

-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
Von: <email address hidden> [mailto:<email address hidden>] Im Auftrag von
Bernat Tallaferro
Gesendet: Dienstag, 5. Dezember 2006 17:23
An: <email address hidden>
Betreff: [Bug 60905] Re: [acx111] default firmware not working for acx
d-linkdwl-g650+

*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 30766 ***

> As described in the following wiki, it should work in edgy.

Note that the wiki says "it seems to work", not that "it should". I
happen to be the one who wrote that, and chose the wording with caution,
since that statement is based on own experience (I own an acx11-based
DWL-G650+) and on posts from the ubuntu forums.

This bug is about the incorrect firmware being loaded at startup.

Your problem is that your wifi card (or the driver) is not functioning
properly I would rather post a separate bug for that, specifying
*exactly* what is not working.

A quick search on the forums seems to hint that such a card should be
working with the acx driver
(http://www.ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=278692&highlight=Zyxel+G-360),
but have you checked that such card is supported by the driver?

--
[acx111] default firmware not working for acx d-link dwl-g650+
https://launchpad.net/bugs/60905

To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers

Remote bug watches

Bug watches keep track of this bug in other bug trackers.