breaks dist-upgrade: E: Couldn't configure pre-depend openoffice.org-core for openoffice.org-filter-binfilter, probably a dependency cycle.

OK got it unstuck by doing:

root@pern:~# cd /var/cache/apt/archives
dpkg --install openoffice.org*

that didn't entirely succeed but it did enough dist-upgrade worked after that
so now I'm up to date :)

Removed openoffice.org-filter-binfilter and upgrade succeeded.

Breaks upgrade.

Michael,

If I remember correctly at the sprint you said you thought this might be a bug of some sort in apt? Does that sound correct with the below package listings?

They both replaces old copies of each other but the versions are from older than Karmic which has 1:3.1.1-5ubuntu1.

Thanks,

Chris

---

Package: openoffice.org-filter-binfilter
Priority: optional
Section: misc
Installed-Size: 27972
Origin: Ubuntu
Maintainer: Ubuntu Core Developers <email address hidden>
Bugs: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+filebug
Architecture: amd64
Source: openoffice.org
Version: 1:3.2.0~rc4-1ubuntu1
Replaces: openoffice.org-calc (<< 1.9.113-0pre1), openoffice.org-core (<< 1:3.1.1~rc1-2), openoffice.org-filter-so52, openoffice.org-math (<< 1.9.113-0pre1), openoffice.org2-core (<= 1.9.108-1), openoffice.org2-filter-so52
Provides: openoffice.org-filter-so52, openoffice.org2-filter-so52
Depends: openoffice.org-core (= 1:3.2.0~rc4-1ubuntu1), libc6 (>= 2.11), libgcc1 (>= 1:4.1.1), libicu42 (>= 4.2-1), libjpeg62, libstdc++6 (>= 4.1.1), ure (>= 1.4.0)
Pre-Depends: openoffice.org-common (>= 1:3.1.0-2), openoffice.org-core (>= 1:3.1.0-2), debconf (>= 0.5) | debconf-2.0, procps
Conflicts: openoffice.org-filter-so52, openoffice.org2-filter-so52
Filename: pool/main/o/openoffice.org/openoffice.org-filter-binfilter_3.2.0~rc4-1ubuntu1_amd64.deb
Size: 6637344
MD5sum: a0b2389b763bfbee1e3815d1252cdfca
Description: full-featured office productivity suite -- legacy filters (e.g. StarOffice 5.2)
 OpenOffice.org is a full-featured office productivity suite that provides
 a near drop-in replacement for Microsoft(R) Office.
 .
 This package contains the "binfilters", legacy filters for
  - the old StarOffice 5.2 formats
  - StarWriter 1.0/2.0
  - StarWriter/DOS
  - *Writer* filters for
    + Excel
    + Lotus
Original-Maintainer: Debian OpenOffice Team <email address hidden>
SHA1: 21cf2ceb2a1fc7487bc3fafd97ea78b8a32cf575
SHA256: 08a0815a7854aeb7937567d9a0cb26313992317c9b4d4fe60b37d0af4f384f85
Homepage: http://www.go-oo.org
Supported: 18m

---

Package: openoffice.org-core
Priority: optional
Section: editors
Installed-Size: 134292
Origin: Ubuntu
Maintainer: Ubuntu Core Developers <email address hidden>
Bugs: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+filebug
Architecture: amd64
Source: openoffice.org
Version: 1:3.2.0~rc4-1ubuntu1
Replaces: openoffice.org (<< 1.9), openoffice.org-bin, openoffice.org-calc (<< 2.2.1~oof680m15-2), openoffice.org-common (<< 1:3.0.1~rc1-2), openoffice.org-filter-binfilter (<< 1:3.1.0-5), openoffice.org-gtk (<< 2.0.3+2.0.4m179), openoffice.org-headless (<< 1:3.0.0~dev300m26), openoffice.org-hunspell, openoffice.org-java, openoffice.org2-core, openoffice.org2-hunspell
Provides: openoffice.org-bundled, openoffice.org-headless, openoffice.org-hunspell, openoffice.org-java, openoffice.org2-core, openoffice.org2-hunspell
Depends: openoffice.org-common (>> 1:3.2.0~rc4), ttf-opensymbol (>= 1:3.0), libc6 (>= 2.11), libcairo2 (>= 1.2.4), libcurl3 (>= 7.16.2-1), libdb4.8, libexpat1 (>= 1.95.8), libfreetype6 (>= 2.2.1), libgcc1 (>= 1:4.1.1), libglib2.0-0 (>= 2.12.0), libgraphite3 (>= 1:2.3), libgstreamer-plugins-base0.10-0...

Assigning to mvo, the package might be wrong but seems to be something in apt itself.

10:20 < mvo> ccheney: I have a look later, it appears we have this bug every
             cycle
10:20 < mvo> s/bug/problem/

Reassigning back to openoffice, debian had the bug too and its fixed there already.

I'm addng a update-manger task to provide a workaround for beta-1. Its not feasible to get a new OOo in time for beta1

This bug was fixed in the package update-manager - 1:0.133.3

---------------
update-manager (1:0.133.3) lucid; urgency=low

  * DistUpgrade/DistUpgrade.cfg, DistUpgrade/DistUpgrade.cfg.hardy:
    - do not allow upgrades to openoffice.org-filter-binfilter that
      causes pre-depends loop (LP: #516727)
 -- Michael Vogt <email address hidden> Tue, 16 Mar 2010 22:59:02 +0100

This bug still exists when upgrading from 9.10 to 10.4 beta despite all updates being installed.

Here's a workaround:
sudo echo “openoffice.org-filter-binfilter hold” | sudo dpkg --set-selections
Then do the dist upgrade

Trying to upgrade from 9.10 to 10.04 LTS but I can't due to this bug.

same here.
openoffice.org-filter-binfilter was not installed.
but i get this error when i try a "update-manager -d"...

after completely uninstalling openoffice, the update is now in progress!

I think this bug is fixed in 3.2.0-4ubuntu1 please follow up to this bug letting me know if you continue to have trouble upgrading due to issues relating to this.

The bug still exists upgrading from 9.10 to 10.4 Beta2. Upgrade failed. I didn't try out by first uninstalling openoffice and run "update-manager -d" afterwards. Will wait for the definitive version before trying again.

Frank: how did you attempt the upgrade? Using 'update-manager'/'do-release-upgrade', or with 'apt-get dist-upgrade'

The bug still exists while trying to upgrade from 8.04 to 10.4 Beta2. Upgrade failed. I used update-manager -d" to upgrade.

With the latest openoffice.org upload this bug has come back, logs e.g. on:
http://people.canonical.com/~mvo/automatic-upgrade-testing/current/lts-main-all/main.log

I used "update manager -d" by clicking Alt F2 and typed the "update manager -d" command. My first install of Ubuntu was 8.04 which I upgraded in several steps to 9.10. I tried to upgrade now to 10.4 Beta 2, which failed.

I used trick proposed by Mouni Mattala posted on top of the topic, to remove the binfilters of openoffice.
Had the pb with "update manager -d" by clicking Alt F2.
Now installing.

There is a merge proposal here:
https://code.edge.launchpad.net/~mvo/openoffice/3.2.0-lucid/+merge/23875

and I uploaded a updated package to my PPA at:
https://edge.launchpad.net/~mvo/+archive/openoffice

I tested the patch and installed/removed packges and also tested karmic -> lucid
openoffice only upgrade that worked fine afaict. I will do more testing tomorrow
including a full upgrade.

Feedback/review of the diff is very welcome.

The code looks good to me overall (and consistent with how I thought this should've been done in the first place!).

Just a few comments:

- you guard the code with checks for 'configure' or 'upgrade'. First, 'upgrade' isn't a supported argument to postinst; second, shouldn't most of the other ways the maintainer scripts are invoked *also* trigger this? I.e., 'postinst abort-upgrade' should certainly restore the registry, and I think 'prerm remove' and 'prerm deconfigure' should as well. I think it's best to not be selective about the maintainer script arguments at all.
- you have code in place to make sure individual components don't register themselves while -core is in an unconfigured state; but there doesn't seem to be any code to ensure that, when -core is configured, it doesn't register *components* that are in an unconfigured state - doesn't this mean there's a window again where things are registered that shouldn't be?

(BTW, it's certainly too intrusive to make this change now for lucid, but this scenario would appear to *exactly* fit the triggers workflow...)

Thanks for the review and your comments!

For the guarding, I used what the "openoffice.org-evolution.postinst" was using. I will update that code according to your comments and talk with upstream about it.

A component in unconfigured state does no harm. When the component shared lib is there (after unpack) it can be registered from -core and again (without ill effects) from the openoffice.org-evolution.postinst.

I updated the code in my branch to remove the check on "configure" in openoffice.org-core.postinst.in

Sounds so similar that this will probably fix also bug #562948. (openoffice.org-voikko circular dependency when trying 8.04 LTS -> 10.04 LTS)

This bug was fixed in the package openoffice.org - 1:3.2.0-7ubuntu4

---------------
openoffice.org (1:3.2.0-7ubuntu4) lucid; urgency=low

  [ Michael Vogt ]
  * change the way components like -evolution or -filter-binfilter are
    registered so that we do not need to pre-depends on
    openoffice.org-core anymore (LP: #516727, #566584)

  [ Matthias Klose ]
  * debian/rules:
    - no not use lzma on armel (LP: #568940)
 -- Michael Vogt <email address hidden> Wed, 21 Apr 2010 09:09:37 +0200

Thanks for fixing this, I think I must have misread Steve's ending comment and thought this fix wouldn't be approved for Lucid. I'm glad to see I misunderstood the comment. :-)

Владислав,

What do you think you are doing? It appears you think you are fixing this bug (assigning it to yourself) and that it is not fixed yet?

Chris