| 2012-12-04 12:03:20 |
K. Bauer |
bug |
|
|
added bug |
| 2012-12-04 12:04:28 |
K. Bauer |
description |
Zim-Version: 0.57 (Windows installer)
OS: Windows 7 64bit
=== Scenario ===
* A page "Page1" contains attachments, e.g. a graphic "image.png"
* A page "Page2" contains
- A link [path/to/Page1/image.png] to the image file.
- The image file inline {{path/to/Page1/image.png}}
- A link [:path:to:Page1] to the other page.
=== Observed Behaviour ===
When Page1 is renamed or moved
* The link [:path:to:Page1] is updated.
* The link [path/to/Page1/image.png] to the graphic is NOT updated.
* The image inclusion {{path/to/Page1/image.png}} of the graphic is NOT updated.
Hence Page2 is broken without warning.
When Page1 is deleted, Page2 is also broken without warning.
=== Expected Behaviour ===
* When an attachment folder is moved or renamed, links to this folder should be updated.
* When an attachment folder needed by other pages is deleted, a warning should be given.
=== How it might be done ===
* This probably implies, that attachments, that are linked to, should be indexed (if it isn't done already).
* Note that attachment folders may have subfolders, that don't correspond to zim pages.
=== Wishful Thinking ===
* When an attachment folder is deleted, but some files are still needed by other pages, the user might be offered to relocate those files to a different page's attachment folder.
* If such a function was implemented, moving attachments between pages should be easy to implement for the Attachment Browser plugin. |
Zim-Version: 0.57 (Windows installer)
OS: Windows 7 64bit
=== Scenario ===
* A page "Page1" contains attachments, e.g. a graphic "image.png"
* A page "Page2" contains
- A link [path/to/Page1/image.png] to the image file.
- The image file inline {{path/to/Page1/image.png}}
- A link [:path:to:Page1] to the other page.
=== Observed Behaviour ===
When Page1 is renamed or moved
* The link [:path:to:Page1] is updated.
* The link [path/to/Page1/image.png] to the graphic is NOT updated.
* The image inclusion {{path/to/Page1/image.png}} of the graphic is NOT
updated.
Hence Page2 is broken without warning.
When Page1 is deleted, Page2 is also broken without warning.
=== Expected Behaviour ===
* When an attachment folder is moved or renamed, links to this folder
should be updated.
* When an attachment folder needed by other pages is deleted, a warning
should be given.
=== How it might be done ===
* This probably implies, that attachments, that are linked to, should be
indexed (if it isn't done already).
* Note that attachment folders may have subfolders, that don't correspond
to zim pages.
=== Wishful Thinking ===
* When an attachment folder is deleted, but some files are still needed by
other pages, the user might be offered to relocate those files to a
different page's attachment folder.
* If such a function was implemented, moving attachments between pages
should be easy to implement for the Attachment Browser plugin. |
|
| 2012-12-04 12:13:05 |
K. Bauer |
description |
Zim-Version: 0.57 (Windows installer)
OS: Windows 7 64bit
=== Scenario ===
* A page "Page1" contains attachments, e.g. a graphic "image.png"
* A page "Page2" contains
- A link [path/to/Page1/image.png] to the image file.
- The image file inline {{path/to/Page1/image.png}}
- A link [:path:to:Page1] to the other page.
=== Observed Behaviour ===
When Page1 is renamed or moved
* The link [:path:to:Page1] is updated.
* The link [path/to/Page1/image.png] to the graphic is NOT updated.
* The image inclusion {{path/to/Page1/image.png}} of the graphic is NOT
updated.
Hence Page2 is broken without warning.
When Page1 is deleted, Page2 is also broken without warning.
=== Expected Behaviour ===
* When an attachment folder is moved or renamed, links to this folder
should be updated.
* When an attachment folder needed by other pages is deleted, a warning
should be given.
=== How it might be done ===
* This probably implies, that attachments, that are linked to, should be
indexed (if it isn't done already).
* Note that attachment folders may have subfolders, that don't correspond
to zim pages.
=== Wishful Thinking ===
* When an attachment folder is deleted, but some files are still needed by
other pages, the user might be offered to relocate those files to a
different page's attachment folder.
* If such a function was implemented, moving attachments between pages
should be easy to implement for the Attachment Browser plugin. |
Zim-Version: 0.57 (Windows installer)
OS: Windows 7 64bit
=== Scenario ===
* A page "Page1" contains attachments, e.g. a graphic "image.png"
* A page "Page2" contains
- A link [path/to/Page1/image.png] to the image file.
- The image file inline {{path/to/Page1/image.png}}
- A link [:path:to:Page1] to the other page.
=== Observed Behaviour ===
When Page1 is renamed or moved
* The link [:path:to:Page1] is updated.
* The link [path/to/Page1/image.png] to the graphic is NOT updated.
* The image inclusion {{path/to/Page1/image.png}} of the graphic is NOT updated.
Hence Page2 is broken without warning.
When Page1 is deleted, Page2 is also broken without warning.
=== Expected Behaviour ===
* When an attachment folder is moved or renamed, links to this folder should be updated.
* When an attachment folder needed by other pages is deleted, a warning should be given.
=== How it might be done / Notes ===
* This probably implies, that attachments, that are linked to, should be indexed (if it isn't done already).
* Note that attachment folders may have subfolders, that don't correspond to zim pages.
* Can be considered related to https://bugs.launchpad.net/zim/+bug/330320 as such file links might sometimes be created as a work-around for copying from pages with images.
=== Wishful Thinking ===
* When an attachment folder is deleted, but some files are still needed by other pages, the user might be offered to relocate those files to a different page's attachment folder.
* If such a function was implemented, moving attachments between pages should be easy to implement for the Attachment Browser plugin. |
|
| 2012-12-17 14:21:18 |
Jaap Karssenberg |
summary |
Cross-page file links are not updated (also affects images) |
Cross-page file links & images are not updated on move or rename |
|
| 2012-12-17 14:21:54 |
Jaap Karssenberg |
zim: status |
New |
Confirmed |
|
| 2012-12-17 14:21:57 |
Jaap Karssenberg |
zim: importance |
Undecided |
Medium |
|
| 2013-04-10 05:17:57 |
Leopooh |
bug |
|
|
added subscriber Leopooh |
| 2013-11-30 17:43:11 |
Andreas Wehler |
bug |
|
|
added subscriber Andreas Wehler |
| 2017-05-19 07:35:51 |
Jaap Karssenberg |
bug watch added |
|
https://github.com/jaap-karssenberg/zim-desktop-wiki/issues/48 |
|
