[R350] [PPC] totem, vlc hang playing movies using xv extension on power g5

Thanks for your report. Can you please try intrepid with the newest -ati driver? Here you can also try Option "AccelMethod" "XAA". Which is the duplicate bug?

Since this is powerpc architecture, I am very cautios in relation to upgrade to unstable version. But I am planning to do that early in September - then I'll try. BTW, would it make sense to build just latest ati driver without full upgrade to intrepid? Does ubuntu apply many patches?

Changing to XAA - I will give it a try.

Hi Sergey,

Ubuntu does not carry a lot of patches against -ati, so building it against your current install would probably be okay.

Hi Bryce

Anyway, I am on intrepid now. Testing...

Hmm, I think I meant Option "AccelMethod" "EXA" because XAA is the default. You may also try Option "AGPMode" "1", since kernel crashes often are related to AGP trouble.

I've cherrypicked a recent Xv fix from upstream, and built this deb for testing:

http://www.bryceharrington.org/ubuntu/Ati/
 xserver-xorg-video-ati_6.9.0+git20080826.a3cc1d7a-2ubuntu4~bwh2_i386.deb

I do not think it fixes this issue, since the issue it fixes is display corruption, not a kernel lockup. However it would be helpful to rule it out, if you wouldn't mind testing it?

You mentioned the kernel is hung when this happens - how are you determining this? If the kernel is hanging, we probably ought to refile this bug against 'linux' and ask ogasawara to look.

Tormod's suggestion of testing AGPMode settings is also a very good recommendation. That option takes values 1, 2, 4, 8. Checking with Option "AccelMethod" "EXA" would also be worthwhile, although I don't think we're ready to switch to EXA over XAA as the default for -ati yet, but if it solves the issue it would be good to know.

So far, intrepid with XAA works ok. I will keep testing. If it does not help, I'll check your .deb Bryce, thanks!

Just yesterday I got it hang again.

Section "Device"
        Identifier "ATI Technologies Inc Radeon R350 [Radeon 9800 Pro]"
        Driver "ati"
        BusID "PCI:240:16:0"
        Option "UseFBDev" "false"
        Option "XAANoOffscreenPixmaps"
        Option "AccelMethod" "EXA"
        Option "AGPMode" "4"
        Option "DRI" "true"
        Option "AddARGBGLXVisuals" "true"
EndSection

Bryce: unfortunately I cannot use your deb, since my machine is power g5 ;)

Also, I have _impression_ (but I am not 100% sure) it happens on 2nd and subsequent movies played within same X session. If I make it hang on the first movie, I'll report.

Additional info (got using ssh): after the screen gets blank, the monitor switches to "no signal" state, Xorg takes almost all of CPU. Cannot be killed (even with -9).

Hi Sergey,

Have you experimented with different AGPMode settings? There are some known issues relating to AGP incompatibilities between the video driver and the host bridge which can cause problems similar to your symptoms. See https://wiki.ubuntu.com/X/Quirks/#ATI AGP Mode Quirk for details.

Hi Bryce

No I did not. Currently it is 4. I will set it to 2 and wait for another hang.

Set AGPMode to 2. X hang (screen and kbd). CPU is busy. It took some while to get to the system using ssh and reboot.

Did you try AGPMode 1?

AGPMode 1 is a disaster. X server takes 233% CPU (on 2-CPU box:), the mouse cursor is moving very slowly, 1/3 (upper) of the screen is black... It took some patience to ssh, change xorg.conf back.

So, it seems only AGPMode 4 makes sense for me now. At least with EXA, DRI enabled.

Okay, thanks for confirming that. 4 is the default so I guess a quirk is unnecessary.

Next I'd like to send this bug upstream for Alex to look at, since I'm out of clue, but he'll want to see the issue reproduced on 6.11.0, so we'll wait until you have a chance to reproduce it on jaunty. Alpha-5 will be released within a couple days and will have 6.11.0 so that would be worth testing against if you just wanted to test a livecd.

When you do get a chance to test again, please attach a fresh Xorg.0.log we can use when forwarding it upstream.

A small update. I cannot really test this fully on jaunty because of #345651. movie players seem to work but somewhat slow...

This bug report was filed against an old version of Ubuntu.
Can you confirm whether this is still an issue in natty?

If you don't mind, it would be very helpful if you could update the bug
report in launchpad to 'Fix Released' if it is no longer an issue for
you, or if it is still occurring under natty, please tag the bug 'natty'
so it's easier for us to track.

Does it make sense to test it with non-released natty (there is no official ISO for PPC)?

Yes, if it is not too much trouble that would be nice. There is no official Ubuntu support, and this issue should probably be forwarded upstream, which will require testing of latest versions.

I will test it once I get bootable 11.04. Currently it is not bootable because of https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/720911

Issue still present in Ubuntu 14.04.

You are right broo https://crackszoom.com/