Some category lists are too long

Bug #475773 reported by Red
22
This bug affects 4 people
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
software-center (Ubuntu)
Triaged
Medium
Matthew Paul Thomas

Bug Description

Not so much a bug, more of a feature request: the category lists are too long, they could be split down a bit to make software a bit easier to find - this could be done with subcategories. Having to sift through a long list of applications, 3/4 of which aren't relevant to the task in mind, is a long and laborious process - splitting the lists into small "bite size" chunks makes it easier to navigate (and is less intimidating), especially for novices.

Example: Sound and video could open up into "Sound Editing", "Video Editing", "Media Playback" and "Music Creation".

<https://wiki.ubuntu.com/SoftwareCenter#Genre>: "These are the departments and subsections, in the order in which they should be presented when presented together..."
____________

2013-02-04: These are the remaining over-long categories, and a basic plan for splitting them up.

* Accessories: Card-sort them into subcategories for "Automation", "Note-Taking", "File Management", "Clocks & Calendars", etc. Propose these as XDG category names, get them adopted, then introduce into USC. (This might result in retiring "Accessories" altogether.)

* Books & Magazines: Subcategorize by publication, e.g. "Full Circle Magazine", "Linux Format Magazine", "Revista Espirito Livre", etc.

* Education: Retire the category. Card-sort and redistribute items into the various "Science & Engineering" and "Developer Tools" categories, plus new categories/subcategories for "Music", "Languages", etc.

* Fonts: Card-sort them into subcategories for "Serif Classic", "Serif Modern", "Handwritten", "Language-Specific", "Symbols", etc. Introduce these as debtags, get them adopted, then introduce into USC.

* Graphics > Viewers: Propose separate XDG "Health", "Medicine", and "Fitness" categories, get them adopted, then introduce into USC, possibly as public "Health & Fitness" vs. practitioner "Medicine".

* Office: Rename to "Productivity", with subcategories for "Finance", "Word Processing", "Databases", etc. Possibly also a "Maps & Reference" category.

* Sound & Video: Propose XDG categories for "Jukebox", "Music Composition", "Media Recording", "Codecs", "Media Server", etc.

* System: Fix the various bugs that cause items to show up here when they're already showing up in another category.

* Themes & Tweaks > All

Revision history for this message
Matthew Paul Thomas (mpt) wrote :

I've now finalized the subcategories for 2.0. <https://wiki.ubuntu.com/SoftwareCenter?action=diff&rev2=349&rev1=348> Ironically enough, "Sound & Video" is one department I don't think we can split at the moment, because there's such a crossover between music players and movie players.

summary: - more categories needed in "Get free Software" pane
+ "Get Software" category lists are too long
description: updated
Changed in software-center (Ubuntu):
status: New → Triaged
importance: Undecided → High
Revision history for this message
Matthew Paul Thomas (mpt) wrote : Re: "Get Software" category lists are too long

For 2.0, Michael has applied subsections to the “Games” and “Developer Tools” departments, and I’ve applied subsections to the “Graphics”, “Internet”, and “Science & Engineering” departments.

These alleviate the problem (so I’m downgrading it to Medium), but with three provisos. First, we’re using a two-pane department screen, so the full long list is still there by default when you navigate into a department. (For version 3, we’ll probably replace the second pane with an “All” button/link in the first pane.) Second, some departments — including Sound & Video, which you cite — don’t yet have subsections at all. And third, in most of the departments that do have subsections, they’re not comprehensive (especially in Games).

The last two problems are related, in that we don’t have enough data to subcategorize those items in a useful way, let alone any mechanism to populate the subcategories if we did. We've been doing an extensive open card-sorting exercise <http://usability.gov/design/cardsort.html> over the past few weeks to help us determine the overall categorization for 2.0 (and we’ll publish results of that soon), but now someone needs to do intensive card-sorting on individual departments. For example, give someone names, screenshots, and descriptions of 70 games — balanced between those currently available for Ubuntu, and those not — and ask them to put the games in whatever categories make sense to them. Repeat with a dozen more people, and collate the results. If anyone would like to organize that, please let us know.

Changed in software-center (Ubuntu):
assignee: nobody → Matthew Paul Thomas (mpt)
importance: High → Medium
milestone: none → later
status: Triaged → In Progress
Revision history for this message
Matthew Paul Thomas (mpt) wrote :

For 3.0, we have done two things to tackle this problem:
1. As I predicted in my previous comment, we've replaced the two-pane department screen with a one-pane screen that ends with an "All {number}" link.
2. In some places, e.g. "Science & Engineering" > "Mathematics", we've hidden non-application items by default with a "Show {number} technical items" link.

What I have not had time to do, though, is any further research on adding more subsections to reduce the length of the "Accessories", "Education", "Office", "Sound & Video", "System", or "Themes & Tweaks" departments. If any usability lab, HCI class, or LoCo would like to help out with Ubuntu, it would be great if they could take even one of these departments and run a card-sorting exercise to work out what the subsections should be.

Changed in software-center (Ubuntu):
milestone: later → none
Revision history for this message
Matthew Paul Thomas (mpt) wrote :

I have now specified subcategories for "Tweaks & Themes" and "Sound & Video". They won't be implemented until the Ubuntu archives have debtags (bug 57418).

Once they are implemented, I think the remaining tasks to fix this bug will be:
- subcategorize, shorten, or replace "Accessories"
- subcategorize, shorten, or replace "Education"
- subcategorize, shorten, or replace "Fonts"
- subcategorize, shorten, or replace "Office"
- subcategorize, shorten, or replace "System".

Revision history for this message
Daan W. (dwynen) wrote :

With more and more games being added I would suggest more subcategories for games, such as "Action."

Also, on the Website I cannot see the Simulation category. Does the website use a different categorization?
If so, why?

summary: - "Get Software" category lists are too long
+ Some category lists are too long
Revision history for this message
Matthew Paul Thomas (mpt) wrote :

Daan W, a subcategory for Shooter games is bug 626414.

description: updated
Changed in software-center (Ubuntu):
status: In Progress → Triaged
To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers

Remote bug watches

Bug watches keep track of this bug in other bug trackers.