Communication from Canonical to the Ubuntu community lacking tact
Affects | Status | Importance | Assigned to | Milestone | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ubuntu-community |
Triaged
|
Undecided
|
Unassigned |
Bug Description
Example is today's announcement of the Ubuntu Single Signon Service: http://
That "blog" post is a Press Release written for a specific audience. However, that audience is not the Ubuntu community of users/developers. Thus, the issues addressed by that PR are not the issues that the Ubuntu community would like to have addressed. Specifically: 1) why the choice was to have the new web service be closed source software by default, 2) why the use of the Ubuntu name/logo was chosen when it is not a community project, 3) what the new features are that make this switch worthwhile, and 4) why this is yet another OpenID provider-
These questions do not and should not be answered in this bug report. That is not the issue at hand.
The issue at hand is the lack of communication from Canonical to the Ubuntu community about these new services. One suggestion was to have both a PR announcement like the above "blog" post in addition to a post from Jono/Daniel/
COMMENTERS: Please keep the comments on this bug report about the communication of new services to the community, not about this specific announcement.
Changed in ubuntu-community: | |
status: | New → Triaged |
Hi Greg,
Just addressing some of your issues, and it seems reasonable to respond to them here:
1) I am not entirely sure of the details why it is closed source, but I do know the components it is built with are open source.
2) The use of the Ubuntu name and logo is because it is an account that provides access to a wide plethora of Ubuntu services such as wiki.ubuntu.com, the Ubuntu store, Ubuntu One etc. It made sense to use the Ubuntu name instead of Launchpad SSO as they are Ubuntu focused.
3) It's purely a branding change, AFAIK.
4) This is primarily a branding change: your existing Launchpad credentials should work fine.
As for the messaging: I agree it is less community focused, but the Canonical Blog is not just for community members. I was planning a blog post on this topic, but I haven't got a chance to write it yet as (a) the SSO service was just announced and (b) I have had to make a last-minute trip to tend to some family issues.
Expect a blog entry from me over the next few days.