Wrong CD retrieved from MusicBrainz for multi cd
| Affects | Status | Importance | Assigned to | Milestone | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Max |
New
|
Undecided
|
Unassigned | ||
Bug Description
I have a 2 CD compilation, "Journey into Paradise, the Larry Levan Story".
I am trying to rip both CDs.
The first one went fine - at first querying MusicBrainz didn't find a match, so I used Max's "Submit Disc ID" feature. I then searched for "Journey into Paradise" on the MusicBrainz site, found http://
I did the same for CD 2 (submitted disc ID, searched for "Journey into Paradise") except this time I chose to associate the disc ID with CD 2 instead of CD 1. The disc ID of CD 2 is S4e_8A4LD_
Perhaps Max isn't compatible with MusicBrainz multi-CD releases?
I was initially using Max 0.9.1. I have tried upgrading to Max r1438 and re-querying MusicBrainz with CD 2 in the drive, but the details for CD 1 are still retrieved.
| Andras Salamon (online-lp-as) wrote | #1 |
I can confirm this behaviour with Max 0.9.1 as well as with r1438. CD 1 works fine, but with disc 2 onwards Max retrieves the descriptions for CD 1. This is the case even for items that are already in the Musicbrainz database (so the description above about submitting disc IDs may not be relevant).
Here is a specific example. Putting disc 2/4 in the optical drive, Max fails to retrieve the description. Pressing "Query" populates the information fields with the descriptions from disc 1 (note that all 4 discs have 10 tracks). Trying to "Submit Disc ID" leads to the correct Musicbrainz page: http://
so this isn't a case of duplicate IDs or a send-side bug.
Perhaps the recent Musicbrainz redesign also changed the way multi-disc items are presented to clients?