| 2014-05-20 09:27:46 |
jazzynico |
description |
I notice that people have opened this bug several times
before and it's been closed with a comment saying "it
already works like it's supposed to". Specifically, the
escape key currently defocuses modeless dialogs, rather
than closing them.
I really think you should reconsider this behavior, for
a couple of reasons:
I (and many other people) are accustomed to Escape
meaning "go away", not "lose focus". I want to be able
to make the dialog vanish easily, because when I'm done
with it, it's just taking up screen space in which I
would rather see my drawing. If I just want to give
focus to another window/dialog...that's what Alt-Tab is
for, it seems to me. While it is possible to close the
dialog with Alt-F4, I'd rather not use that key
combination for this purpose, for two reasons: 1) it's
harder to type, 2) if I inadvertently type it with the
main window focused, then it will try to close my
document and the whole app. Having the Escape key close
non-essential windows, but do nothing to the main app
window is nice, because I know that hitting Escape is
always "safe", and it will always take me closer to the
"default" UI state, where just the main app window is
open.
I (and many Linux users) prefer to use X11-style "focus
follows mouse" behavior, instead of Windows-style
"click to focus" behavior. With this style of mouse
interaction, the Escape key meaning "defocus dialog"
offers zero added benefit, since I can defocus the
dialog simply by pointing away from it.
Thanks |
I notice that people have opened this bug several times before and it's been closed with a comment saying "it already works like it's supposed to". Specifically, the escape key currently defocuses modeless dialogs, rather than closing them.
I really think you should reconsider this behavior, for a couple of reasons:
I (and many other people) are accustomed to Escape meaning "go away", not "lose focus". I want to be able to make the dialog vanish easily, because when I'm done with it, it's just taking up screen space in which I would rather see my drawing. If I just want to give focus to another window/dialog...that's what Alt-Tab is for, it seems to me. While it is possible to close the dialog with Alt-F4, I'd rather not use that key combination for this purpose, for two reasons: 1) it's harder to type, 2) if I inadvertently type it with the main window focused, then it will try to close my document and the whole app. Having the Escape key close non-essential windows, but do nothing to the main app window is nice, because I know that hitting Escape is always "safe", and it will always take me closer to the "default" UI state, where just the main app window is open.
I (and many Linux users) prefer to use X11-style "focus follows mouse" behavior, instead of Windows-style "click to focus" behavior. With this style of mouse interaction, the Escape key meaning "defocus dialog" offers zero added benefit, since I can defocus the dialog simply by pointing away from it.
Thanks |
|
