"Free codecs" is an incorrect phrase

Bug #38620 reported by Alex Chekholko
4
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
EasyUbuntu
Fix Committed
Medium
Unassigned

Bug Description

Under the Media tab, there is a checkbox called "Free codecs: Add Support for playing mp3 and other non-free formats".

First of all, "Support" shouldn't be capitalized.

Second of all, IMHO "add support" is a vague statement and should be removed.

Third of all, both Free and "non-free" are used in the same sentence, ostensibly describing the same codecs.

I recommend the line be changed to "Codecs: for playing mp3s and other non-Free formats"

Then, because the next line reads "Binary codecs: Add support for proprietary video and audio formats" the user is expected to know the difference between "binary" and "non-binary" and "Free" and "non-free" and "proprietary". It's not clear to me what that difference is. Perhaps there is an even better way to word this?

Another alternative is to follow the Ubuntu project an call the formats "Free Formats" and "Restricted Formats" like here:
https://wiki.ubuntu.com/RestrictedFormats
https://wiki.ubuntu.com/FreeFormats

A further question is: would anyone want to install the "Free Codecs" but NOT the "Binary Codecs"? IMHO, no, so maybe you should just combine all the codecs into one checkbox?

Revision history for this message
Alex Chekholko (alex-chekholko) wrote :

After looking through the text in the rest of the program, the messages are inconsisted throughout: some say "install" others "enable", still others have no verb.

I tried editing the messages.pot file in my easyubuntu directory, but that didn't change the text of the program when I ran it.

Revision history for this message
Venkat Raghavan (venkatraghavan) wrote : Re: [Bug 38620] "Free codecs" is an incorrect phrase

On Friday 07 April 2006 12:48, Alex Chekholko wrote:
> Description:
> Under the Media tab, there is a checkbox called "Free codecs: Add
> Support for playing mp3 and other non-free formats".
>
> First of all, "Support" shouldn't be capitalized.
>
> Second of all, IMHO "add support" is a vague statement and should be
> removed.
>
> Third of all, both Free and "non-free" are used in the same sentence,
> ostensibly describing the same codecs.
>
> I recommend the line be changed to "Codecs: for playing mp3s and other
> non-Free formats"
>
> Then, because the next line reads "Binary codecs: Add support for
> proprietary video and audio formats" the user is expected to know the
> difference between "binary" and "non-binary" and "Free" and "non-free"
> and "proprietary". It's not clear to me what that difference is.
> Perhaps there is an even better way to word this?
>
> Another alternative is to follow the Ubuntu project an call the formats
> "Free Formats" and "Restricted Formats" like here:
> https://wiki.ubuntu.com/RestrictedFormats
> https://wiki.ubuntu.com/FreeFormats
The codecs for playing free formats come preinstalled with Ubuntu.

EasyUbuntu installs the free implmentation of the codecs required to play
restricted formats.

This should be more clear.
> A further question is: would anyone want to install the "Free Codecs"
> but NOT the "Binary Codecs"? IMHO, no, so maybe you should just combine
> all the codecs into one checkbox?
Binary codecs are codecs like w32codecs, which might be illegal to install
(Todo: Warning sign) in a few countries. These are x86 architecture specific.
Hence I will not combine then into one checkbox.

Maybe this should also be made clear in EasyUbuntu Documentation
(https://launchpad.net/products/easyubuntu/+spec/easyubuntu-documentation).

Changed in easyubuntu:
status: Unconfirmed → Confirmed
Revision history for this message
KarlGoetz (kgoetz) wrote :

The docs have had a line " The free codecs are freely available, open source codecs for playing restricted media formats" added at Rev 16

Revision history for this message
Kyle Brooks (kyle-brooks) wrote :

fixed in revision 266

Changed in easyubuntu:
status: Confirmed → Fix Committed
To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers

Remote bug watches

Bug watches keep track of this bug in other bug trackers.