Rank analysis is wrong

On 05/10/2012 08:18 PM, Johan Hake wrote:
> mesh = UnitCube(5,5,5)
> VV = VectorFunctionSpace(mesh,"Lagrange",1)
> u = TrialFunction(VV)
> v = TestFunction(VV)
> Aij = diag(Constant((1,1,1)))
> Delta = Identity( mesh.ufl_cell().geometric_dimension())
> # Does not work (but works with sfc)
> assemble(inner(Aij*(grad(u)+Delta), grad(v))*dx)
> # Works
> assemble(inner(Aij*grad(u), grad(v))*dx)

As far as I can see, your form has different ranks.
The error message then seems very correct.

--

Marie

On 10 May 2012 19:34, Marie Rognes <email address hidden> wrote:
> On 05/10/2012 08:18 PM, Johan Hake wrote:
>> mesh = UnitCube(5,5,5)
>> VV = VectorFunctionSpace(mesh,"Lagrange",1)
>> u = TrialFunction(VV)
>> v = TestFunction(VV)
>> Aij = diag(Constant((1,1,1)))
>> Delta = Identity( mesh.ufl_cell().geometric_dimension())
>> # Does not work (but works with sfc)
>> assemble(inner(Aij*(grad(u)+Delta), grad(v))*dx)
>> # Works
>> assemble(inner(Aij*grad(u), grad(v))*dx)
>
> As far as I can see, your form has different ranks.
> The error message then seems very correct.
>

And that would then make it an SFC bug ;).

Garth

> --
>
> Marie
>
> --
> You received this bug notification because you are a member of FFC Core
> Team, which is subscribed to FFC.
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/997739
>
> Title:
>  Rank analysis is wrong
>
> To manage notifications about this bug go to:
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/ffc/+bug/997739/+subscriptions

On 05/10/2012 08:34 PM, Marie Rognes wrote:
> On 05/10/2012 08:18 PM, Johan Hake wrote:
>> mesh = UnitCube(5,5,5)
>> VV = VectorFunctionSpace(mesh,"Lagrange",1)
>> u = TrialFunction(VV)
>> v = TestFunction(VV)
>> Aij = diag(Constant((1,1,1)))
>> Delta = Identity( mesh.ufl_cell().geometric_dimension())
>> # Does not work (but works with sfc)
>> assemble(inner(Aij*(grad(u)+Delta), grad(v))*dx)
>> # Works
>> assemble(inner(Aij*grad(u), grad(v))*dx)
>
> As far as I can see, your form has different ranks.
> The error message then seems very correct.

grad(u).rank() == 2
Delta.rank() == 2
Aij.rank() == 2
(grad(u)+Delta).rank() == 2
(Aij*(grad(u)+Delta)).rank() == 2

Can you point our where it is wrong?

Johan

There is a difference between tensor rank and form rank. You are printing
the tensor ranks. The form rank would be number of Arguments.
So, in your example:

  (grad(u) + Delta) * grad(v) = grad(u)*grad(v) + Delta*grad(v)

The first term on the right-hand side has form rank 2 (there is a TestFunction
and a TrialFunction involved) while the other has form rank 1 (just a TestFunction).

DOLFIN can only assemble (and FFC only generate code for) forms
in which all terms have the same (form) rank.
In short, you can't add a matrix and vector together.

On 10 May 2012 19:45, Johan Hake <email address hidden> wrote:
> On 05/10/2012 08:34 PM, Marie Rognes wrote:
>> On 05/10/2012 08:18 PM, Johan Hake wrote:
>>> mesh = UnitCube(5,5,5)
>>> VV = VectorFunctionSpace(mesh,"Lagrange",1)
>>> u = TrialFunction(VV)
>>> v = TestFunction(VV)
>>> Aij = diag(Constant((1,1,1)))
>>> Delta = Identity( mesh.ufl_cell().geometric_dimension())
>>> # Does not work (but works with sfc)
>>> assemble(inner(Aij*(grad(u)+Delta), grad(v))*dx)
>>> # Works
>>> assemble(inner(Aij*grad(u), grad(v))*dx)
>>
>> As far as I can see, your form has different ranks.
>> The error message then seems very correct.
>
> grad(u).rank() == 2
> Delta.rank() == 2
> Aij.rank() == 2
> (grad(u)+Delta).rank() == 2
> (Aij*(grad(u)+Delta)).rank() == 2
>
> Can you point our where it is wrong?
>

The form ranks are mixed up - u is a TrialFunction and Delta is a
constant. You're mixing linear and bilinear forms.

Garth

> Johan
>
> --
> You received this bug notification because you are a member of FFC Core
> Team, which is subscribed to FFC.
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/997739
>
> Title:
>  Rank analysis is wrong
>
> To manage notifications about this bug go to:
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/ffc/+bug/997739/+subscriptions

On 05/10/2012 08:54 PM, Marie Rognes wrote:
> There is a difference between tensor rank and form rank. You are printing
> the tensor ranks. The form rank would be number of Arguments.
> So, in your example:
>
> (grad(u) + Delta) * grad(v) = grad(u)*grad(v) + Delta*grad(v)
>
> The first term on the right-hand side has form rank 2 (there is a TestFunction
> and a TrialFunction involved) while the other has form rank 1 (just a TestFunction).

Tensors, smensors!!

> DOLFIN can only assemble (and FFC only generate code for) forms
> in which all terms have the same (form) rank.
> In short, you can't add a matrix and vector together.

Will target this as a bug for sfc :)